Silvia Moreno-Garcia, Velvet Was the Night (2021)

Author: Silvia Moreno-Garcia

Title: Velvet Was the Night

Format: E-book

Pages: 304

Series: –

The newest Silvia Moreno-Garcia’s book is a historical noir mystery/crime, set in the simmering danger of 1970s Mexico, when both the people and the country seemed inescapably gripped in a continuous, dispiriting turmoil. Whatever else you’ve read by this author, Velvet Was the Night might still surprise you. There’s not a whiff of supernatural anywhere; well, except for the very real horror that humans are capable of. There’s also not much of a romance, or beauty. Indeed, Velvet Was the Night is a surprisingly political book, depicting violent actions of increasingly more desperate, more ruthless factions of an internal conflict fueled by ideology, economy, and foreign interests. While its scope and stakes seem small – no grand assassinations or rebellions, no dramatic political shifts, just common people caught between a rock and a hard place – the ultimate price is still paid in the most valuable currency: human life and decency. 

Throughout the novel we follow two protagonists, at first glance seeming as different from each other as they could possibly be: Elvis, a young member of the historical right-wing, government-trained paramilitary organization called Hawks (los Halcones) who were responsible for the Corpus Christi massacre in 1971 in Mexico City, in which over a hundred protesters were killed; and Maite, a 30-something secretary escaping her routine, lonely life into romance comics and American music. For Elvis, the membership in the Hawks is a form of social advancement; it gives him an anchor, a place of belonging, and means for learning new skills. Maite feels trapped in her own life, depressing and meaningless, always on the verge of debt; she makes up her own fantastic stories just to escape the dreary reality she doesn’t feel she can change. Neither of them is a revolutionary, a saint, or an idealistic warrior for truth or justice; they are just trying to scrape by. But in the 1970s in Mexico City even a shred of conscience or a simple coincidence might put you in trouble – as both Maite and Elvis will learn. Their fates draw close and finally intersect when evidence incriminating the Hawks in the students’ massacre goes missing, hidden somewhere by Maite’s rebellious but connected neighbor, Leonora. 


While Velvet Was the Night  has only two main protagonists, it boasts of an impressive supporting cast. There are secret police and art collectives, nosy neighbors (and one very vexing mother), frightened journalists, poor students and snobby heirs to family money, KGB agents and Jesuit priests, and hapless moles. I won’t spoil any more plot details; suffice to say Moreno-Garcia managed to craft a classic, politically flavored noir, with characters in every shade of grey, an abundance of moral ambiguity, a claustrophobic feeling of no escape, and no clear-cut happy endings. While the plot is somewhat predictable, the Chekhov’s guns all going off in the final act in equally satisfying and saddening ways, what really matters in Velvet Was the Night is the ride, not the destination. It is heartfelt and heartbreaking in its depiction of the young and old Mexicans, raised and broken by the system, often misguided even in what they firmly believe is right, often openly corrupted by the power they enjoyed, by the fear and pain they were subjected to. I couldn’t help but be reminded of the fate of my own country in that strange, tumultuous time: while the ideological poles might have been reversed, the policies, the methods, the dilemmas were the same.

The dual perspective of Elvis and Maite works very well indeed; while it gives the plot the necessary dynamics, it also serves a non-literary, maybe even more important purpose. It would be easy to show only one point of view, to firmly point a finger to the victims and the perpetrators; but Moreno-Garcia avoids that trap of attribution and makes the whole story so much more believable and humane. She doesn’t absolve the killers, she doesn’t lionize the protesters; by showing the inner workings of the system, clandestinely influenced by both CIA and KGB as just another proxy conflict of the Cold War, treated as a bid for power and money by various internal factions, she refers the final judgment to the reader.

While at first glance Velvet Was the Night seems unlike any other Moreno-Garcia’s work I’ve read, on a deeper level it’s still the same grand arc she writes in her every book: a story of the human search for connection. A story of imperfect, broken people looking for a bit of happiness in a world that’s anything but; a story of resilience and hope, surprising even for the protagonists themselves. And even though Velvet Was the Night is probably the most depressing of Moreno-Garcia’s books I’ve read so far, it is also weirdly satisfying in a way her other books weren’t. Maybe it’s the historical setting, and the very real circumstances in which the plot takes place; maybe it’s the noir character of the novel, subdued and gray, but also incredibly apt, considering the times it is depicting. Maybe it’s the bitter-sweet nostalgia cut with abrupt horror and underscored by the sentimental, throaty songs that play incessantly in the background, creating a unique mood – there’s a whole playlist here, and Moreno-Garcia kindly supplies all the titles at the end of the book (there’s even an accompanying Spotify playlist, if you want to enhance your experience). Whatever the reason, that hard-to-pinpoint, amorphous, moody presence makes Velvet Was the Night the best of Moreno-Garcia’s books I’ve read. It certainly won’t be the last, too – she’s a highly versatile, talented author with plenty of interesting stories to tell.

All in all, Velvet Was the Night is a well-crafted, intriguing historical political noir; a sweet and sad song to Mexico’s past, a heartfelt character study, a subdued maybe-romance hidden beneath puddles of blood and broken teeth.

I have received a copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. My thanks.

Score: 8.5/10

20 thoughts on “Silvia Moreno-Garcia, Velvet Was the Night (2021)

    1. Yup; the action erupts in intimate level violence (knives, beatings, an odd gun up close) from time to time, but mostly it’s very low-key: surveillance gigs, waiting, spying etc.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. A positive review from the critical Ola! I still want to read Mexican Gothic after all the noise that was made about it, but it’s good to know she’s an author who maintains the high standards she has attained.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh, come on! I do write positive reviews now and then! 😉 Mexican Gothic is a gothic delight, certainly. This one is more historical, delving into the turbulent not-so-distant past of Mexico. Both are worth a read, Chris! 😀

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, do give it a shot! I hope you’ll enjoy it even though the mystery is somewhat predictable and on the back burner 😉 but as a character study (and a portrait of Mexico) it works very well indeed!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Pingback: Winding Up the Week #184 – Book Jotter

  3. This is such an amazing review! I have never read a book by this author, even if sooner or later I would try at least one of them. I am a bit thorn because she seems to write pretty unique books, and I have read a ton of interesting reviews about them, and yet there is something that I can’t pinpoint but that put me off. It is like the whole atmosphere, from what I gathered from the review, os not the right one for me. But at every interesting review I read my curiosity grows, so… I would try at least one of them, sooner or later. Thanks for sharing this one!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I think you’d actually enjoy Moreno-Garcia’s books, Susy! Maybe The Beautiful Ones would be a good place to start? It’s less creepy than Mexican Gothic and less historical than Velvet… And it still features unique female protagonists and lush, elegant prose 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Someone seems to be a huge fan of the author! 😀 After that last one that unfortunately disappointed you, I would’ve imagined more reticence for anything but I guess she proved us all wrong with quality story-telling. Really interesting that each of her books seems so different from one another but still has something in common that you managed to identify! Fantastic review, Ola! 😀

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Moreno-Garcia’s yet to disappoint me (unlike, say, Tchaikovsky, whose exploits I now follow with more wariness :P), so yeah – I’m always curious about her new projects 😀 Even The Beautiful Ones were all right, though romance is most definitely NOT my favorite genre 😀

      Yup, part of Moreno-Garcia’s skill is her ability to write so diverse books – from gothic to contemporary noir to historical romance etc. Now I have her dark fantasy on my TBR!

      Thanks, Lashaan! 😊

      Liked by 1 person

  5. I’ve leapfrogged through your thoughts on this one, just enough to see that you’ve enjoyed it; it’s on the “soon” arm of my unwieldly stack (was lucky to get one of the first lot of library loans) and am keen to explore. Hopefully I remember to come back here after I’ve read it!

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s