Raymond Feist is a fantasy author best known for his Riftwar saga – an epic fantasy cycle telling the story of a war between two worlds. The saga is set on Midkemia – a world very much like medieval Europe, or, to be more precise, like Tolkien’s Middle-earth. I wouldn’t go as far as to say that Midkemia is a brutal rip-off of Tolkien’s world, but Middle-earth is definitely a very strong inspiration for Feist. The world of Midkemia is basically feudal Europe, with plenty of castles, keeps, villages and cities, but most of all full of forests and roads – long and winding – leading through them. It’s populated mainly by people, sure, but also by dwarves and elves, trolls and goblins, dragons and magicians.
My first encounter with Feist was, paradoxically, not through any installment in the original Riftwar saga (starting with a classic Magician), but with a spin-off of sorts, a trilogy set on the other side of the magical rift – on the world of Kelewan. The Empire Trilogy, as it’s called, was the effect of collaboration between two writers: Raymond Feist and Janny Wurts. Wurts is a fantasy artist (she makes covers for her own books) and a writer in her own right, albeit much less popular than Feist – the Empire Trilogy remains her most popular work to date.
In the Empire Trilogy we see the other side of the coin: the world of invaders who ruthlessly conquer Midkemia. It is a very interesting approach all in itself – I will compare it to the rather improbable situation (definitely not viable in our leg of Time’s pants) where Tolkien himself would create an account of the war in Middle-earth from the perspective of Sauron and his orcs. Not very likely, huh? Although others have already done it, even if later than Feist and Wurts…
Kelewan is a mirror image of imperial Japan from Shogun’s times, when the Emperor was god but the real political power resided among various noble clans viciously fighting with each other. A mirror image, but with a few slight differences: on Kelewan the sun shines stronger, there are no seasons, the beasts of burden have six legs, there is no metal whatsoever, and the world is inhabited not only by humans, but also by cho-ja – a sentient race of ant-like insectoids. The whole world of Tsuranuanni is held rigid by a complicated set of rules and traditions – so many of them and so constraining, that virtually no progress is possible.
In this setting we meet Mara of the Acoma – a young girl who wished to become a priestess but because of a family tragedy is forced to become the head of her clan. Her family, the Acoma, were once very powerful but now are decimated, leaderless and weak. Weakness among Tsurani is highly dangerous. It is seen by others as an opportunity to gain more power – simply by murdering all the remaining members of the hapless family, taking over their lands and business, and, last but not least, obtaining something maybe less tangible but equally important – fame and honor.
Through three weighty books we accompany Mara on her tortuous road to power. We witness the evolution of Mara’s character: a would-be nun, far away from worldly affairs, becomes a ruthless and talented politician, addicted to the Game of the Council, getting high on power. And only after some personal tragedies – and when her personal stakes become entwined with the policies of the whole Empire – she becomes something more. Mara is a very well-written character. A strong woman, sure, but the scope of her humanity – and inhumanity – is not in the least limited to her gender. We see her as a leader faced with tough decisions, as a parent, a lover, a politician, a victim as well as a perpetrator. We see her blunder and succeed in turns, we see her crying, compromising her own values, broken and breaking others. We also see her grow and change – not only herself, but the world around her as well.
It is a world worth knowing – multi-faceted, realistic, well-thought and well-written, and populated by many increasingly interesting characters. We learn a lot about the Tsurani ways of fighting, doing business, growing crops and selling needra hides, but most of all we get to know various customs, traditions and ways of life. Of course, most of it is nothing new, really – we’ve seen it all through Clavell’s eyes in his famous Shogun, but still, Feist’s and Wurts’ attempt deserves a praise.
It is a rare case when a collaboration of authors brings fresh fruits instead of rotten – and I can attest to the fact that the Empire Trilogy is such an exception. It is very well written, fast-paced but at the same time rich in detail. The many characters populating the Tsurani world are each given well-deserved depth; sometimes in a few strokes, sometimes through a lengthy psychological study, but in the majority of cases they ring true. We come to like and hate them, root for or against them, to appreciate their little ways. We have a chance to get irritated, troubled and fascinated by their stories, their decisions and fates. We understand them, and this is the biggest advantage of the Empire Trilogy novels as a whole – the people seen in the Riftwar saga as alien, and their ways incomprehensible, become known; different, sure, but at the same time fathomable.
Of course, it is all much easier to digest when in the second installment a Midkemian barbarian comes into the fray, to promote the civilized Western mindset. As I said, Shogun all around. And we of the barbaric origins feel rightly appeased ;).
There are some slight drawbacks – the first installment, Daughter of the Empire, reads a bit like an old-fashioned computer game: the choices of the main characters are very limited, the events trickle one at a time, at a steady pace, and it takes the authors a considerable time to find their cooperative footing. There is also a rather improbable amount of good luck involved, but then Mara of the Acoma starts from a very unfavorable position. Tthe book does get better, however, and the slow beginning gives the readers an opportunity to get immersed in the world of Kelewan. The second installment, Servant of the Empire, is more evenly paced and has the best bad guy in the whole trilogy 🙂 But, as I said before, it is very Shogun-like. I prefer to treat is as a tribute instead of rip-off, but I freely admit it’s a very close thing. The third installment, Mistress of the Empire, is the biggest and most ambitious in scope, but also the least probable. There are several authors’ choices, especially at the end of the novel, that I can’t agree with: they seem forced.
All in all, the Empire Trilogy is a really good read. Not original and a bit naive at times, but written with flare – and heart. It’s a rare enough thing in our times to be treasured as it rightly deserves.
Score: book I 8/10, book II 8,5/10, book III 8/10
5 thoughts on “Raymond Feist, Janny Wurts, Empire Trilogy (1987–1992)”
First of all – link to “The Last Ringbearer” was not necessary. One of the worst books I’ve ever tried to read, and by “tried” I mean I gave up after a couple of pages – and I finished WoT out of sheer stubbornness. The idea was interesting, but instead of giving the other side some depth, author just reversed the moral order of Middle Earth… if you want complicated, morally dubious Elves, read Sapkowski.
As for the main topic… “Shogun meets Tolkien” – sounds great. Tolkien is King, and Shogun I enjoyed immensely (as the rest of Clavell’s books).
But, if we have to start without “western barbarian” protagonist’s eyes to filter this new world through… would I enjoy this trilogy as much :P? Probably, I’m way more open-minded than I pretend to be 😉 And there was a million of Riftwar Saga books after that, so I don’t think Empire conquers entire Free World in this installment 😉
It’s not jumping to the top of my “to-read” pile, I think I will start with Feist’s first novel, I have a very nice edition of it somewhere, but I’m convinced to give it a try one day.
PS.: Wow! So famous “Betrayal at Krondor” is taking place Feist’s world… and there was an official novelization… and speaking about old computer games, they often offered a much wider variety of choices than modern ones 😛
I haven’t read “The Last Ringbearer” – from what you’re saying it’s pretty awful, but I liked the idea of Mordor’s industrial revolution and the idea of “political history”. A shame, then, and a good advice not to get acquainted with the book.
As for the computer games, I was rather thinking of “Prince of Persia” type of the game 😛
The Empire Trilogy takes place on Kelewan exclusively – for the actual Riftwar you would need to look to the original Midkemia books, starting with “Magician” – and, btw, your “Magician” is currently being read by me, so you don’t need to search through your library any longer 😉
Pingback: Janny Wurts,The Master of White Storm (1992) | Re-enchantment Of The World
My first encounter with his books is the Magician’s Apprentice and I loved what it had to offer. I’m now a bit shocked that I still haven’t made time to continue on with that trilogy but at least I know that I can expect only good things from it! I also know he has done A LOT of other trilogies, all inter-connected in one way or another (??) and I’m glad to hear of this one. It sounds pretty good for a double-author trilogy. Thanks for sharing this one with us! 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
I think I have Magician’s Apprentice review somewhere here as well 😉
Honestly, I think this one’s better. I really liked the more nuanced perspective both authors offered here, experimenting with showing the other side of the conflict in a way that far exceeds the fantasy norm. Hope you’ll find time to read this one, Lashaan! 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person